See the Big Picture: The
Tipping Point of Epidemics
Tipping
Point on Dread Diseases
The Tipping Point is the point where something changes. Studies of how
change happens give us sharp insights into how to structure programs.
Once we understand change and tipping points, the more we can use it
to our advantage.
Rule
1: Change happens fast. The Measles Campaign was a concept in early
2001. In less than 3 years the Measles Campaign cut deaths from measles
in Africa by half, by a total of about 200,000/year. These results occurred
while they were designing, testing and polishing their methods.
The
2004 Measles Campaigns is projected to lower the death toll by another
200,000, equal to all the lives saved the first few years. Change can
accelerate. The first few years the measles campaign saved a couple
hundred thousand lives. Now that the methods are refined, they are rolled
out and campaigns can go into the harder areas to cover. In prior areas
monitoring and mop up campaigns continue to lower rates ever further.
Within 5 years of starting the death toll from measles in Africa should
be down by over 90% and falling further.
Never
in history has a killer mass disease fallen so far so fast - with as
few inputs. Measles may be past the Tipping Point already. Measles is
not yet eradicable, but it may be soon. The Measles Campaign set
the stage for other inputs. One such input is the Insecticide Treated
Net.
Rule
2: Little things make a difference. Insecticide Treated Nets are
small things that have a big impact. Cover the children of sub-Saharan
Africa and save a million lives per year. Every $1 put into ITNs puts
$20-100 into the economy. That's impact.
Rule
3: The broken windows theory. When windows stay broken, local conditions
decline. The more the graffiti, the more broken windows appear in a
neighborhood, the larger and more serious the crime becomes. Deterioration
snowballs.
Happily,
the reverse is also true. Small things matter. Clean up the graffiti,
fix the windows and the crime rates drop. In some cases, crime plummets.
Positive change also builds on itself.
In
1990 New York City had over 2000 homicides. As part of an overall campaign,
officials undertook a number of small things. Among other things, they
cleaned up graffiti and fixed broken windows. 2003 saw fewer than 100
murders in New York City. Violent crimes dropped dramatically.
Providing
mosquito nets gives the entire community a visible sign of participation
in health care. We know that ITNs have a huge impact on health care
within families and on the system as a whole. Put a net in every house
and the hospital visits may drop by 25% or 40%.
Rule
4: The Role of Visible Leaders. The rule goes like this: when a
community has leaders playing roles visible to the public, order prevails.
Like broken windows, the problems arise in the absence of sightings
of leaders.
Where
community leaders are visible more than a particular amount, problems
appear to stay under control. When the leaders don't make themselves
seen or heard. Problems rise. Researchers noticed that when visible
sightings of leaders fall below a particular point, then a whole raft
of bad things all spiked up quickly and almost in concert. When fewer
leaders appeared in the communities being studied, crime, truancy, drug
usage, juvenile delinquency and teen pregnancies all changed for the
worse almost overnight. The chart of the change looks like a dogleg.
The change is not a continuation of earlier trends. The shift is non-linear.
What
is more important than saving lives? There is little doubt that communities
that receive vaccines or mosquito nets are better off with these goods.
Might another 'good' that is delivered outweigh the importance of the
goods? The 'good' has a double meaning here, that of seeing a community
volunteer participate in a public way in activities that help the community.
How about saving communities?
What
messages does the Measles Campaign send to communities? The Measles
Campaigns are run almost entirely by volunteers. The volunteer participants
are unpaid in conventional terms, and still achieve unconventional success.
The volunteers appear in public on a regular basis in visible roles
that help the communities. Perhaps the most valuable payoff for the
communities, the most valuable 'input' is the visible public service.
The millions of volunteers provide role models for the children, youth
and people of all ages in each country. The studies in the Tipping Point
suggest that the visible volunteer service may be most valuable contribution
to the campaigns and their country overall.